Year	Result
2009	Somerset Hills (Bernardsville) 10, Haddonfield 5
2008	Bordentown 14, Pequannock 3 (4 innings)
2007	Randolph East 7, Jackson Township 2
2006	Livingston American 10, West Milford National 0 (5 innings)
2005	Toms River American 10, South Vineland 0 (4 innings)
2004	HTRBA (Hamilton) 4, Millburn-Short Hills 0
2003	Freehold Township American 3, Ridgewood National 0
2002	Nottingham (Hamilton Square) 4, Millburn-Short Hills 3
2001	Randolph West 11, South Vineland 10
2000	Pequannock 3, South Vineland 2
1999	Toms River East American 3, Pequannock 2
1998	Toms River East American 7, Randolph 4
1997	North Hunterdon (High Bridge) 10, Cherry Hill American 7
1996	Millburn-Short Hills 3, HTRBA (Mercerville) 2
1995	Toms River East American 19, North Hunterdon 5
1994	Millburn-Short Hills 8, North Vineland 4
1993	Nottingham (Hamilton Square) 5, Toms River 1
1992	Nottingham (Hamilton Square) 16, Clark 1
1991	South Vineland 8, Morristown National 3
1990	Brick National 11, North Trenton 10 (7 innings)
1989	Championship game not played due to rain; Cherry Hill American is awarded title as the winner's bracket champion.
1988	Jersey City Roberto Clemente 7, Morristown National 5
1987	Nottingham (Hamilton Square) 6, Old Bridge 5 (7 innings)
1986	Cherry Hill American 9, Morristown National 5
1985	Morristown National 4, Nottingham (Hamilton Square) 0
1984	Palisades Park 5, Cherry Hill American 1
1983	Cherry Hill American 7, Morristown National 6
1982	Morristown National 12, Nutley Central 7
1981	Bernardsville-Basking Ridge 10, River Edge 5
1980	Margate City 4, Morristown National 2
1979	Ridgewood National 4, Cliffside Park 3 (7 innings)
1978	Elizabethport 8, Bergenfield National 3
1977	North Edison 6, Cherry Hill American 5
1976	Union American 6, North Edison 5
1975	Lakewood 5, Nottingham (Hamilton Square) 2
1974	Livingston American 6, Bergenfield American 1
1973	Lodi American 13, Hillsborough 7
1972	Howell Central 7, Ventnor 3
1971	Wallington 4, Bound Brook 3
1970	Wayne American 6, Garfield American 1
1969	Nottingham (Hamilton Square) 4, Gloucester City 1
1968	Wallington 4, Collingswood 3
1967	West New York American 11, Franklin Township 0
1966	West New York American 3, Upper Saddle River 1
1965	Margate City 1, Fort Lee National 0
1964	Tenafly 5, Collingswood 4 (10 innings)
1963	Tenafly 4, West New York American 0
1962	Pitman 8, River Edge 1
1961	Sayreville 9, River Edge 3
1960	West New York American 4, Haddonfield 0
1959	East Rutherford 2, Chambersburg (Trenton) 0
1958	Englewood American 4, Runnemede 3
1957	Blackwood 4, Par-Troy Hills (Parsippany) 3 (7 innings)